Noise cancelling vs noise isolating which is better?

Noise cancelling vs noise isolating which is better?

When buying a good headset, knowing the difference between noise cancellation and noise isolation is crucial.

Depending on your particular lifestyle (i.e., a constant traveler, working in a hectic office, being the parent of toddlers, operating heavy duty machinery, etc.), choosing the right headset can be the chasm that divides you from absolute heaven or sonic hell.

In this piece, we will try to elaborate on both of them so you can make an informed decision: Lets have a discussion on Noise cancelling vs noise isolating.

Difference between Noise Cancelling vs Noise Isolating

Noise canceling

Noise canceling headsets “listen” the incoming low range sounds of your surroundings (traffic, engines running, air conditioners) to create inverse waves of “anti-sound” that suck them into the current music you are listening.

In other words, they cancel the outcoming noises, making you feel like the world has become a little quieter around you.

This phenomenon is called destructive interference.


Why You Should Buy Noise Cancelling Headphones

Noise canceling headsets are perfect to enjoy your favorite tunes in low-stress, low-hectic places, like a bus or a train, but they will be entirely useless for the high-bustle, high-hustle of an 8-hour long flight with toddlers or a small office full of chatty people.

They protect the health of your eardrums, preventing loud and the constant low-level noises to damage your hearing.

They can be more comfortable for more extended periods, they are safer for your ears’ health, and they can remove the annoying sounds pretty well.
The vast majority of them require batteries and/or charging to function, quality can vary tremendously, and the best of them aren’t precisely the cheapest.

Noise isolating

Noise isolating headsets act as a barrier between your ears and the ambient noise, and, in the majority of cases, are better against medium-range sounds (babbling, crying, music, high-pitched screams).

Some can still let lower-level noises pass through their barriers, so maybe you should choose your battles wisely in this regard.

But there are differences between on ear and in ear headsets: On-ear headsets muffle the sounds while in-ear earphones depend on the quality of the “sound sealing” to completely isolate your ears from the sounds of the world around them.

However, in the end, it reduces to which type is more comfortable for you.

Because every ear is a world in itself and what works perfectly for your best friend cannot necessarily be you’re happily ever after.

In the case of better headsets, a formable foam is used, which allows it to mold effortlessly to the shape of your ear.

They can cancel the sounds around you rather well which is perfect if noise tends to distract you, works wonderfully for musician types because it does not affect the audio quality and the music can be entirely appreciated.
In-ear headsets can feel crampy against your eardrums, the best fit for you can be a little harder to find, and not all of them are as comfortable as they should be.

TIP: If you want to test the bass quality and the overall performance of a headset, try listening to Bohemian Rhapsody through it.

This song is perfect for this, because it contains the broadest range of highs and lows, thus making the testing of a new headset a little more thorough.

Look at this video for differences in Noise cancelling vs noise isolating.

Which one to choose?

It is inaccurate to testify that the first time is better than the second type, we actually recommend you to make a verdict based on your lifestyle, budget, and preferences.

The big difference between those two is that noise isolating headphones can block noise due to their materials; while noise-canceling do the same, but they use high tech to cancel sound waves.

Consequently, noise cancellation headsets are evaluated mainly based on the tech they use.

Experts usually agree with the fact that noise cancellation is more useful as they can include as well the noise isolation feature.

Unfortunately, prices are generally high for this type of tech, leaving many consumers to still go for simple noise isolation headsets.

Moreover, canceling seems to be our imminent future. Recently, Apple and their competitors have started to integrate noise-canceling tech into their processes.

The main reason was the Iphone7 revolution a year ago when they shocked global markets by eliminating the 3.5mm jack.

Some tips for choosing the right type relies on deciding if you are an in-ear or on-ear lover, as well as analyzing the several places in which you will be using them.

If you are the type of person that travels 24/7, cancellation is your way to go. Otherwise, to exercise or to merely going to work, isolation is a great idea.

Also, we strongly recommend you to evaluate which type of headphones interacts better with your ear.

Over ear headphones come with the feature of covering your ear completely, which produce a better sound result (although, they are bulkier than the rest).

On the other hand, you have on-ear and in-ear headsets, the first type is lighter, and they rest over your ear canal, while the second type, in-ear, is quite similar but some say that it’s more comfortable as they are placed inside the ear canal.

Looking for a summary? Simple! For noise isolation goes for on-ear and in-ear headphones, for canceling purposes you should surely go for over-ear ones.

Isolation vs. cancellation also comes with a wired vs. wireless choice.

If you are the type of worker that sits in a computer for long periods and wants to listen to all your laptop´s playlist, then wired headphones suits you better (and as we said, they are cheaper!).

For the ones that are always moving around, wireless headphones are the best option out there (regrettably, if they run out of battery your mood-booster is dead till you find a proper charger).

We know that in the end, you should let your ears decide for you.

However, just in case, here a list of the best noise-isolating earbuds within marketplace:

To close the chapter, here are some recommendations for canceling types of headsets:

  • The Sony WH-1000XM2 is the favorite option of many! They have named the best 2019 noise-canceling headphones, and they have a long-lasting battery.
  • Bose QuietComfort 35 II is the second in the list of experts, as it provides a clear sound stage and their battery is even better than the Sony version. It also includes Google Assistant that will answer any doubts any time!
  • The Wireless version of Sennheiser (PXC 550) is an excellent additive to your bucket list; it has aptX connectivity and fantastic sound quality.
  • Philips Fidelio NC1, Bose QuietComfort 25, AKG N60NC Wireless and Plantronics BackBeat Pro 2 are also located at the top of our list, and we strongly recommend you to experience the features.
  • Lastly but not least, if you were asking yourself for a product able to combine isolation and cancellation, then the Audio Technica ATH-ANC7B is the perfect solution and the best part, they are quite affordable!.

Wrap up:

Now as you are clear about the Noise isolating and Noise canceling headsets, you can easily choose your best fit.

If you have decided on which one to choose, you can check out our lists and reviews on SoundinOut to get the best value-for-money.

Let us know in the comments below about your choice and budget; we will provide the best list based on your requirements.